Survivor All Star 2025 faced a major controversy involving Almeda Baylan, who is under scrutiny for allegedly applying violence to staff and breaking rules by secretly taking food and personal items from outside the designated areas. The incident led to an emergency council meeting where host Acun Ilıcalı announced that Almeda could face disqualification or severe penalties after evidence showed she had physical contact with a female staff member and took items from an unauthorized villa. Ilıcalı emphasized that physical violence is unacceptable and stated that if the severity of the violence was confirmed, Almeda would be disqualified from the competition. During the council, Almeda expressed her frustration, claiming she was pushed and pushed herself over the edge. The decision to disqualify her was finalized, with Ilıcalı citing her physical assault on four staff members, including a female worker, as the primary reason. Almeda broke down in tears, apologizing and expressing regret for her actions. Meanwhile, Batuhan Karacakaya received a penalty of two days off the island and five immunity wins, for participating in the rule-breaking behavior. The controversy has kept the show's audience and social media buzzing, raising questions about her future in the competition and the strict disciplinary measures enforced by the show's management.